Sunday, November 23, 2014

You are here

Zimbabwe's Marange Diamonds Push Kimberley to the Brink

In Zimbabwe, the Kimberley Process has failed to regulate the diamond industry and its human rights abuses.
Share |
Panning for diamonds: the illicit diamond trade has kept authoritarian leaders in power and funded a number of conflicts on the continent. Photograph by Brian Harrington Spier.

Conflict diamonds first gained prominence on the international stage following the extensive research on ‘Blood Diamonds’ conducted in the 1990s by international NGOs such as UK-based Global Witness and its Canadian counterpart Partnership Africa Canada (PAC).

This research described how unregulated diamond deals with rebels in Angola, Sierra Leone and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, caused untold suffering to these nations’ citizens. Rebels directly exchanged diamonds for weapons, which were then used against their own people in a quest for power.

Amongst the most notorious rebels benefiting from such deals was Sierra Leone’s Foday Sankoh of the Revolutionary United Front (RUF) and Angola’s Jonas Savimbi of UNITA, which reportedly earned over $4billion from rough diamond sales between 1992 and 1997.

The conflicts in Angola and Sierra Leone, full of brutal atrocities and crimes against humanity, took the lives of over a million people, funded and fuelled by the trade of diamonds.

The Kimberley Process

The exposure of this darker side of the diamond industry led 37 diamond-producing states as well as partner NGOs to sign the Kimberley Certification Process Scheme (KP) in Switzerland on November 2002. KP was subsequently endorsed by the UN General Assembly Resolution 55/56.

Today, over 75 nations are engaged in the KP with the objective of stemming the flow of conflict diamonds, which are defined as those “used by rebel movements or allies to finance conflicts aimed at undermining legitimate governments”.

However, this definition is problematic and many argue that such an approach does not reflect today’s realities. Much of this controversy has centred on the diamond trade in Zimbabwe, eventually leading to the withdrawal of founding member Global Witness from the process in December 2011.

‘Blood Diamonds’ and Zimbabwe

Over the past three years, President Robert Mugabe's government has been accused of human rights abuses including the indiscriminate killing of civilians in the new diamond mining fields of Marange, Manicaland Province in the east of Zimbabwe.

According to a Global Witness report, these deaths can be attributed to the “violent assaults by government security forces against diamond diggers and local communities”. It continues: “Hundreds of people have been killed, and many more have been beaten, raped and forced to mine for the army and police. But in the face of overwhelming evidence, the Zimbabwean authorities continue to deny that these abuses have occurred, and no-one has been held accountable.”

According to this same report, Global Witness notes that “the violence in Marange reached a peak in autumn 2008, with the arrival of the army, and the launching of Operation ‘Hakudzokwi’, or ‘You will not return’. This operation appeared to have two goals: to ensure control of the diamond deposits for the ZANU-PF elite, and to reward the army for its loyalty to this clique. More than 800 soldiers were deployed alongside helicopter gunships, killing over 200 people”.

An ineffective process

Since events in Zimbabwe first reached the KP in 2008, little has been done to effectively address the situation. And, during the June 2011 Plenary Session of the KP in Kinshasa, the process’ chairman Mathieu Yamba unilaterally pushed for Zimbabwe’s diamonds to be cleared to re-enter mainstream diamond trade. At the session, the unrestricted sale of Marange diamonds was re-approved to the delight of many top-level Zimbabwean politicians.

The decision to abandon the KP by NGOs and other observers such as Ian Smillie points to the KP's lack of efficiency as well as its outdated mandate. Despite new regulation, ‘blood diamonds’ are a reality in many parts of Africa funding illegitimate groups and governments.

Additionally, artisanal miners continue to work under deplorable conditions and are often underpaid or unpaid. Child labour is an unfortunate reality in countries like Zimbabwe, Sierra Leone, the DRC and Angola. Civil wars which were initially associated with diamonds may have subsided but the working conditions for most artisanal miners have not improved dramatically. Often these miners are abused by their own governments or the lucrative deals their leaders make with western businesses help sustain corrupt and authoritarian regimes.

Any hope for the Kimberley Process?

The KP can only succeed if human rights triumph over politicking. With the US at the helm of the KP (as chair of its rotating chairmanship) many look to the US State Department to reconsider the plight of Zimbabweans and other Africans. On the one hand, progress looks unlikely especially as the KP continues to welcome new and questionable member countries such as Cameroon, whose leaders are implicated in well-documented human rights abuses.

On the other hand, there are some faint indications of a change of attitude on the horizon. Gillian Milovanovic, the current chair of the KP, for example, suggested on a visit to India that Zimbabwean diamonds may soon retain their illicit label.

“There is an urgent need to redefine the term 'conflict diamond'” said Milovanovic, adding, “I consider Zimbabwe diamonds as ‘products under sanction'”.

Think Africa Press welcomes inquiries regarding the republication of its articles. If you would like to republish this or any other article for re-print, syndication or educational purposes, please contact: editor@thinkafricapress.com

Share |

Comments

You need to stop and think rather than regurgitate staff that you have read in books without putting your own thoughts. Why should powerful nations continue to use the starngulation of a target country to bring about a client state. We want self governance based on equality not servitude.

Consumers have been deceived and conned into believing that the only blood diamonds are those in the pockets of gun-slinging, sabre-wielding black African rebels. However, the trade in blood diamonds that fund government forces is flourishing – a fact confirmed when the Kimberley Process, ignoring pleas from NGOs,  approved the export of diamonds from the Marange area of Zimbabwe where government forces stand accused of gross human rights violations including, the killing 200 people in 2008. Of even greater concern is the trade in diamonds crafted in Israel. According to evidence given to the Russell Tribunal on Palestine, revenue form the Israeli diamonds industry generates $1 billion per year in funding for the nuclear-armed apartheid regime. Israel stands accused of serious war crimes and possible crimes against humanity by the UN Human Rights Council following its assault on Gaza in the winter of 2008/2009 that killed over 1400 people, including more than 300 children.Israel is one of the world’s leading manufacturers/exporters of cut & polished diamonds. Jewellers deceitfully claim Israeli diamonds are conflict free – a totally unjustified assertion given Israel’s record of gross human rights violations and breaches of international human rights law and humanitarian law. NGOs have so far ignored the issue of Israeli blood diamonds but increasing numbers of people are learning about the clandestine trade in Israeli blood diamonds. Google Israeli blood diamonds for further information.

"Child labour is an unfortunate reality in countries like Zimbabwe, Sierra Leone, the DRC and Angola". This statement shows that this writer does not have even the least information about Zimbabwe diamonds. It  also shows that the writer simply picked information from the internet without. If your website needs to remain relevant you have to crosscheck some of these facts. No sane Zimbabwean would read will continue reading this website if it is carrying such distorted information. Your writers need to be on the ground and see what is happening, being a professor is not good enough... be there talk to the people and you will learn the truth.